It was 20 years ago on Monday (November 18th) that Nirvana taped its appearance on MTV Unplugged, with the results being perhaps that program's greatest segment and a live album considered by many to be among the top concert recordings in the history of rock. According to Yahoo! Music, the show came off without a hitch despite coming close to being a disaster or never even happening at all, due to frontman Kurt Cobain's arguments with MTV and his bandmates, as well as his worsening health and addiction problems.
- Cobain and drummer Dave Grohl were not getting along during the rehearsals, with Cobain continually asking Grohl to play his parts softer.
- Grohl recalled in 2006, "In rehearsal, we would do a song, and Kurt would turn to me and say, 'Hey, do you think you could play it a little bit lighter?' . . . So we'd do another take, and he'd turn around and go, 'Could you bring it down just a little bit more?' And we'd do another take, and he'd say, 'You know what, just still, could you bring it down?' And I was like, 'Should I even f***ing be here?'"
- MTV apparently freaked out when the network learned that half the set was going to be obscure cover songs and that the band would not perform "Smells Like Teen Spirit," which it had not played live for nearly two years at that point.
- The MTV brass was not taken with the band's selection of guests either. Producer Alex Coletti recalled, "They wanted to hear the 'right names' -- Eddie Vedder or Tori Amos…But when I said 'the Meat Puppets,' it was kind of like, 'Oh, great. They're not doing any hits, and they're inviting guests who don't have any hits to come play. Perfect.'"
- Cobain told MTV the day before the show that he was canceling the taping, but then relented. An MTV exec said, "He did it just to get us worked up. He enjoyed that power."
- A dress rehearsal several hours before the taping went so badly, however, that MTV execs wondered if they should have let Cobain cancel after all.
- According to Cobain biographer Charles Cross, Cobain was also suffering from gastrointestinal problems and heroin withdrawal, and had been "vomiting bile and blood."
- Despite all the problems beforehand, the taping went off without a hitch -- with Coletti later recalling, "With most Unpluggeds, we tend to run through the set, have a chat, and then do a few songs over again. But this was truly one take -- every song, straight through, in one hour . . . this was really tight -- something like 56 minutes from start to finish."
- Bassist Krist Novoselic later said, "Doing MTV Unplugged was a lot of fun…It was a Nirvana triumph, but it's also Nirvana Lite. But it was cool that we managed to pull it off."
DID YOU KNOW?
- Kurt Cobain was so nervous about the Unplugged taping that he asked people he knew -- from MTV, his record label and his management -- to sit in the front row. But he also did not want his wife Courtney Love or their infant daughter Frances present at the session.
- Nirvana had done a previous all-electric taping for MTV in 1992, but Cobain was so unhappy with it that he only allowed the channel to air one song.
- Although it was supposed to be performed by the entire band, "Pennyroyal Tea" was performed solo by Cobain -- a decision made on the spot during the actual taping. Cobain asked aloud, "Am I doing this by myself or what?" To which Dave Grohl answered, "Do it yourself."
- MTV execs begged Cobain for one more song after finishing the set with a cover of Leadbelly's "Where Did You Sleep Last Night?" Producer Alex Coletti recalled, "Kurt finally said, 'I can’t top that last song.' And when he said that, I backed off. 'Cause I knew he was right.”
- Five of the six cover songs performed during the taping mentioned death. Cobain died five months later, in April 1994. The album, MTV Unplugged In New York, was released in October 1994 and went on to sell nearly seven million copies in the U.S.
CHECK IT OUT: Watch a historical segment on the making of Nirvana's Unplugged episode:
INTERNET COMMENTS at Yahoo! Music -- agree or not?
mark wrote: "I think everyone in charge of programming at MTV today should be forced to watch this, as well as the Alice in Chains show, just to see what MTV once was."
jeff wrote: "The only interesting MTV Unplugged episode from start to finish. It had you wanting more time on it. The last song is hauntingly brilliant."
Darkseer wrote: "I've got to say that there were much more classic shows from MTV Unplugged. Kurt Cobain and Nirvana were NOT good musicians from the technical sense, but they could sell the emotion of a show."
Heath Lane wrote: "There are many reasons why Nirvana's 'Unplugged' was one of, if not THE best of that show's history. It's sad that there was so much torment and turmoil to make it happen, and that it essentially threw the first handful of soil onto Cobain's casket. But what a triumphant conclusion nonetheless."