Although Dave Grohl says he's been reluctant to play any music from Nirvana live in the past, performing recently at Sound City Players gigs with former Nirvana members Krist Novoselic and Pat Smear has made it more of a possibility. In fact, Grohl revealed to NME that the three of them had discussed doing it -- and asking British alternative diva P.J. Harvey to sing. Grohl explained, "Every once in a while we talk about it. For the Sound City gig here in London (last month), we were thinking about musicians that we could invite because Stevie Nicks and John Fogerty couldn't make it. Someone came up with the idea of doing a Nirvana song with P.J. Harvey."
Grohl added, "Kurt (Cobain) loved her and we love her and we thought, 'Yeah, what would we do?' I said, 'God, what if we were to do "Milk It" from In Utero with Polly (P.J. Harvey) singing?' We all looked at each other like, 'Whoa, that would be amazing,' and then she couldn't do it."
- Grohl reiterated his reluctance to play Nirvana material, saying, "The thing is, it's sacred ground. If we were ever to do something like that it would have be right because you want to pay tribute. There's a reason Foo Fighters don't do Nirvana songs, and it's a good reason."
- The Sound City Players, a collection of musicians that Grohl interviewed for his documentary Sound City, played what might have been their last show at the South By Southwest festival in Austin, Texas last week.
- We asked Grohl about the possibility of taking the Players on the road: "You know, so many people have said like, 'Oh, you've got to go on tour' and 'You've got to do more shows' and I swear to God, I would give my left arm to do it. Logistically, you could imagine, it's like taking Hollywood Squares on the road. It's nuts."
- Sound City: Real To Reel, the soundtrack album companion to the movie, debuted at Number Eight on the Billboard album chart on Wednesday (March 20th), selling 37,000 copies in its first week of release. The set includes new songs featuring Grohl, Paul McCartney, Trent Reznor, Corey Taylor, Stevie Nicks and others.
WHAT DO YOU THINK??
- Do you think it would be okay for the surviving members of Nirvana or even the Foo Fighters to play some Nirvana songs live?
- Or is it "sacred ground" as Dave says, to be left alone?
- If they did play it, who do you think would be a good singer who could do it justice?
INTERNET COMMENTS at Loudwire -- agree or not?
Ykcir Rekrap wrote: "pj would've been a great fit...she loved nirvana as well!!"
KC Recchio wrote: "WE MISS YOU KURT."
Danny Wayne Makemson wrote: "It would be nice if it was only to be done as a tribute. I think PJ's perfect."
Art Dumas wrote: "What about the lead vocalist from Puddle of Mudd...perfect!!"
Dave Grohl On Whether The Sound City Players Could Tour
Read more at Blabbermouth, Loudwire, Rolling Stone and NME